Cat & Fiddle Review, Harvester


“We are proud of our freshly prepared food, warm welcome and relaxing atmosphere.”

Cat and Fiddle ChristchurchThese are the words that greet us on the home page of the Harvester website.  The truth is that sadly none of them apply to any of the Harvester locations we have visited this past July in Dorset.  What a disappointment it is to look forward to a tasty and well-cooked meal, only to be greeted with dried up, or overcooked offerings, served by wait staff who have a careless attitude and would rather be anywhere but at work.

We have both returned from the USA in the past couple of years and have been greatly dismayed to see how little customer service is offered in the UK, how staff have little interest in going the extra mile, or offering their services with a smile and a polite word, and have to admit that the Brits could learn a thing or two from their cousins on the other side of the Atlantic.

Our first visit to a Harvester restaurant was to the Cat & Fiddle in Christchurch.  Upon walking from the parking lot to the restaurant we noticed that the majority of the tables in the garden outside still lay sitting with dirty leftovers, empty beer bottles/glasses and no availability for a new arrival to sit without having to waitress their own table.   We, therefore, opted for a table inside, though on closer inspection perhaps the lawn outside would have been preferable.  A very tired looking dining area greeted us and certainly a good intense clean of every piece of upholstery, table and chair were greatly needed.

The food was mediocre, except for the BBQ chicken which was pretty tasty and thus since we had a little left over we requested a doggy bag – it appears this is something a little unacceptable to the Brits, or perhaps just the young woman who served us.  She returned the ‘doggy bag’, chicken wrapped in cling film, with the bones hanging out the end, dumped it down on the table and walked off.   No friendliness, no smile, nothing.  In fact, it appeared that the staff were getting ready to end their shift so were trying to rush customers along, and certainly asking for anything extra was a great frustration to them.    After requesting the bill the waitress returned to pick up the payment asking how much change we required – insinuating that she would be taking a tip from whatever cash we had given her.  We made it clear that we required all the change, of course.   In our minds, tipping only comes with good service and nothing could be further from the truth at The Cat & Fiddle.

However, being gluttons for punishment we decided to return to the ‘scene of the crime’ a couple of weeks later, only to be treated with more disdain than the first time.  Again the tables were left in a state of mess and confusion from the previous inhabitants, and thus we chose to sit in the garden, far away from the ‘disaster area’.  We’ll keep this short but basically, after 40 plus minutes of waiting for our appetiser our main course arrived at which point we told the waitress to cancel that part of the order and refund our money, we had a sneaking suspicion that our order had been given to another customer.  After all, that waiting, can you believe it, the main course was inedible – a beef burger so charred and dry one couldn’t bite into it.   The rest of the food on the plate was cold.  An extremely disappointing and annoying exercise, one that we will not put ourselves through again.

Our waitress was very understanding and agreeable when we complained about the food, and she agreed to refund our money.  However, upon returning to the kitchen with our complaint she told us she was given abuse from the kitchen staff, through no fault of her own.  She was also very apologetic for the behaviour of the staff on our previous visit and went on to explain that the owners cared little for their staff, paid them little, and gave little training, something that is greatly needed in our opinion.   If only the owners of these restaurant chains were more inclined to train and nurture their staff they would find happy employees willing to go the extra mile and also a commitment to the job. Instead, these employees take their lead from a lackadaisical boss, and then the boss wonders why there is no commitment!

Our final words on this are: don’t bother to set yourself up for disappointment, go elsewhere for a friendly face and tasty sustenance!

Cat & Fiddle Harvester
Lyndhurst Rd, Hinton,
Hampshire BH23 7DS
Tel: 01425 276050





  1. The cat is out of the bag about this place and you are right but too kind to them it is rubbish food at it’s best. The menu sounds great but food very poor with rude staff. All Harvesters are becoming like this. The one by the river between Southbourne and Christcurch made me wait with kids for 55 minutes to let me know they forgot the order no apology no refund I had no choice but to eat there as kids were hungry and already waited so long. Never again!

  2. I am afraid that it is typical of treatment from staff at Harvester. We used their restaurants for years with absolutely no problems – then it became absolutely horrendous. Son in Law’s debit card was cloned and the only time it was used was in a Harvester. We changed to a different location and all started off well – then we had one absolutely dire experience, which even the letter giving us free main courses cannot tempt us to return. It wasn’t only us – it was the whole section. I likened the experience to eating in McD’s but without the service for someone to take me to task and say McD’s have no cutlery. Well – neither did we in the Harvester.

    The doggy bag – we always ask for a doggy bag – got two cats and a GSD who can be bribed into forgiving us for eating out by bringing back a little treat – it is only ever wrapped in cling film. At Frankie and Bennies it is put into a container, then wrapped and placed in a bag. Good service for leftovers.

    But – Harvester changed their menu from proper cooked food to a ‘grill/BBQ’ – fast food in anyone’s langauge, very hit and miss when doing more than one thing. If I eat out I want a gastropub/restaurant experience. If I want fast food I will go to Burger King, the food is nicer and not a lot dearer.

  3. It is unfortunate as it is such a great location with a large outside seating area, but still not enough to make me go back there.

  4. The Harvester at Eastlciffe in Bournemouth is also horrendous, dirty and a general unkempt appearance! Food was mediocre and the eating area was full of workmen swearing. Noticable lack of staff. Won’t be going to Harvester again, they’ve done with us now!

  5. Since the new management have taken over, there has been an amazing improvement! Give them another chance. I did and I don’t regret it.

  6. Hi Becky. In actual fact the new management had contacted us and offered for us to go back to the Cat and Fiddle after it had been under the new management for a couple of months while they get their feet on the ground.

    We did call them back but they didn’t want to know. A staff member mentioned to me that there are more positive reviews than negative ones online!

  7. You have to realise how poorly paid the staff will be, going the extra mile is common in the states because of the tipping culture, however in England staff have to make do with minimum wage, long working hours and more often than not a job that isn’t secure. Cut em some slack.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.